Jury Deliberations Begin In Harvey Weinstein Rape And Assault Trial
Jury Deliberations Begin In Harvey Weinstein Rape And Assault Trial

Weinstein trial ‘not a vote on #MeToo’

Judge James Burke has cautioned jurors in the Harvey Weinstein rape trial that their verdict is "not a referendum on the #MeToo movement".

Weinstein lawyer Donna Rotunno sent a similar message in a Newsweek essay over the weekend, drawing complaints from a prosecutor who said she appeared to be trying to influence the jury.

 

Ms Rotunno wrote that Weinstein's jurors "have an obligation to themselves and their country, to base their verdict solely on the facts, testimony and evidence presented to them in the courtroom," not critical news stories, unflattering courtroom sketches or other outside influences.

Confronted about the essay in court, Ms Rotunno said she was writing "about the jury system as a whole" and was not speaking to the jury in Weinstein's case.

Lawyer Donna Rotunno with client Harvey Weinstein. Picture: Getty
Lawyer Donna Rotunno with client Harvey Weinstein. Picture: Getty

Assistant District Attorney Joan Illuzzi-Orbon said Ms Rotunno's essay was "100 per cent inappropriate."

She asked Judge Burke to instruct the jury to ignore the piece and revoke Weinstein's bail and send him to jail because, she argued, it couldn't have been done without his permission.

 

Judge Burke denied the prosecution's request, but told Weinstein: "I would caution you about the tentacles of your public relations juggernaut."

Two weeks ago, Ms Rotunno was criticised in court and on social media for an interview she gave to The New York Times podcast The Daily in which she blamed victims for getting sexually assaulted.

Lawyer Donna Rotunno. Picture: Getty
Lawyer Donna Rotunno. Picture: Getty

Jurors at the trial began deliberating in a case which has pitted accusers' often-harrowing testimony against the defence's contention that the acts were consensual, surrounded by friendly, flirtatious emails and further meetings with the film producer.

Weinstein has denied all allegations of non-consensual sex.

 

Mann leaving the court, with assistance, after two torrid days in the witness stand. Picture: Reuters
Mann leaving the court, with assistance, after two torrid days in the witness stand. Picture: Reuters

The panel of seven men and five women received instructions in the law from the judge before beginning to weigh charges that Weinstein raped a woman, Jessica Mann, in a Manhattan hotel room in 2013 and forcibly performed oral sex on another woman, TV and film production assistant Mimi Haleyi, in 2006.

 

Jurors will also be weighing actress Annabella Sciorra's account of a mid-1990s rape in considering charges alleging Weinstein is a sexual predator, even though the allegation is too old to be charged on its own due to statute of limitations in effect at the time.

Actress Annabella Sciorra. Picture: AP
Actress Annabella Sciorra. Picture: AP

Other accusers testified as part of the prosecution's effort to show he used the same tactics to victimise many women over the years.

A torrent of allegations against Weinstein in October 2017 spawned the #MeToo movement.


Community ‘strongly opposes’ proposed CQ mining project

Premium Content Community ‘strongly opposes’ proposed CQ mining project

The proposed open cut coal mine expects to mine up to five million tonnes per annum...

Mining giant accused of taking covert photos of child

Mining giant accused of taking covert photos of child

Private investigator working for Adani photographed child

UPDATE: Friend finds man badly hurt after quad bike crash

Premium Content UPDATE: Friend finds man badly hurt after quad bike crash

The man sustained serious head and spinal injuries in the overnight crash.