Witness credibility under attack in murder trial

Gold Coast murder victim Shaun Barker.
Gold Coast murder victim Shaun Barker. Photo Contributed

THE motivations behind a key witness's testimony in Shaun Barker's murder trial have come under attack.

Brisbane Supreme Court heard witness Matthew Paul Dean would ring up accused killer Stephen "Snoop" John Armitage to abuse him and swear at him.

Mr Armitage, his son Matthew Leslie Armitage and William Francis Dean, no relation to Matthew Dean, have pleaded not guilty to killing Mr Barker.

Crown prosecutor Glenn Cash has alleged in December 2013 the trio tortured and killed Mr Barker, stuffing him into an esky, burning his corpse and dumping it in a forest.

The court heard Mr Barker was involved in the drug trade and had a large drug debt.

Matthew Dean previously told the court around Christmas 2013 William Dean asked him if he would "babysit" someone who the three had been brutally beaten as they "needed him to talk". Matthew Dean said he thought it may have been a joke and laughed it off.

He told the court he was then told the three were going to put the man in an esky.

But on Tuesday Tin Can Bay man Rodney Austin told the court Matthew Dean would call Stephen Armitage to abuse him.

He said he heard Mr Dean on the phone to Stephen Armitage having "hostile" conversations about a belief that Mr Armitage was sleeping with Mr Dean's former partner.

Under cross-examination from defence lawyer Tony Kimmins, Mr Austin admitted he heard Mr Deans abuse Mr Armitage, calling him a "dog c***" and asking "what kind of a mate are you?".

Mr Austin denied Mr Deans had ever stayed at his house, but said he would simply "come around", until in mid-January Mr Austin's housemate told him to stay away.

Earlier in the trial Mr Deans admitted he had a long-running dispute with Stephen Armitage about the issue and about fishing holes.

But Mr Deans denied to the court that dispute was impacting his testimony in the case. He said he and Stephen Armitage had "fought over fish our whole lives".

The trial continues.


Topics:  matthew leslie armitage shaun barker murder stephen john armitage william francis dean

Stay Connected

Update your news preferences and get the latest news delivered to your inbox.

Future of telecommunication

Kristy Sparrow from Better Internet for Rural, Regional and Remote Australia (BIRRR).

Survey allows rural Australians to voice their concerns.

Taking a national stand

NO WAY: Students from Year 8 created 'No Way' bullying posters to show bullying has no place at Emerald State High school.

Local high school raises awareness against bullying.

Inland Port announced

ECONOMIC BOOST: Federal Member for Flynn Ken O'Dowd makes the funding announcement at the Central Highlands Development Corporation's Economic Futures Forum on Monday.

Ken O'Dowd announced federal funding for two major projects.

Local Partners